When Silence Is Misread
Rethinking Student Voice in Culturally Diverse Classrooms
Runner Up, 2026 Student Writing Award, British Association for International and Comparative Education (BAICE)
By Gifty Kwaofio8 min read

Who gets to speak in the classroom?
At the beginning of the school year, I was developing classroom agreements with my Grade 1 students. We were discussing the expectations we wanted to establish as a learning community when one student confidently suggested a rule:
“Kids don't talk or ask questions. Only adults and teachers do.”
Almost immediately, other students disagreed. Some shook their heads, while others openly challenged the suggestion.
What struck me was not simply the disagreement, but what it revealed about the different understandings of respect, authority and participation that children bring into the classroom.
For some students, speaking up, asking questions and sharing opinions are natural parts of learning. For others, listening quietly and allowing adults to lead may be closely connected to how they have learned to demonstrate respect.
That moment made me reflect on a question I believe deserves greater attention in education:
When we encourage student voice, whose understanding of voice are we actually promoting?
Student voice is not culturally neutral
Student voice and agency have become increasingly important in contemporary education. Across many international schools, students are encouraged to ask questions, make choices, express opinions and take greater ownership of their learning.
These are valuable educational goals. However, the ways we recognize and encourage student participation are not always culturally neutral.
Research suggests that cultural beliefs influence how children understand authority, communication and their roles within learning environments (Nyamekye et al., 2025).
In many Ghanaian contexts, attentive listening and deference to adults can be understood as expressions of respect. Meanwhile, educational approaches influenced by Western traditions may place greater emphasis on questioning, verbal participation and openly expressing individual perspectives.
These differences do not mean that one approach is necessarily better than the other. Rather, they invite us to consider how educational expectations are shaped by cultural values.
In international schools, where students often come from diverse cultural backgrounds, these tensions can become particularly visible.
Poonoosamy (2018) raises important questions about the extent to which international education reflects genuinely diverse perspectives or continues to privilege Western understandings of learning and participation.
This raises a concern: If schools recognize student agency primarily through visible verbal participation, are we overlooking students who express engagement differently?
Silence does not always mean disengagement
In classrooms, participation is often associated with what we can observe.
We notice the student who raises a hand, contributes to discussions or confidently asks questions. These behaviours are frequently interpreted as signs of engagement and independence.
But what about the student who listens carefully, observes others or takes time before contributing?
Silence can have different meanings.
A student may be processing information, demonstrating respect, feeling uncertain or choosing not to participate. We cannot assume that silence automatically represents engagement, just as we cannot assume that speaking always demonstrates meaningful agency.
Vygotsky's sociocultural theory offers a useful way to understand these differences. The theory emphasizes that learning and development are shaped through social relationships and cultural experiences (Rubtsov, 2020).
Children do not arrive at school with identical understandings of what it means to participate. Their beliefs about who speaks, who listens and how authority operates have already been influenced by the environments in which they are growing up.
Returning to my classroom experience, the student's suggestion was not simply a rule about classroom behaviour. It reflected an understanding of how children and adults should interact.
Rather than immediately treating that understanding as incorrect, I believe moments like these offer opportunities to explore the cultural assumptions that shape our classrooms.
Rethinking what meaningful participation looks like
Recognizing different cultural understandings of participation does not mean discouraging children from asking questions or expressing their opinions.
Nor does it mean assuming that silence is always a positive expression of respect.
Instead, it means creating learning environments where students can develop their voices without feeling that their cultural identities must be set aside.
For educators, this requires looking beyond a single definition of participation.
It might involve offering students different ways to contribute, including small-group discussions, drawing, writing, partner conversations or opportunities to reflect before speaking.
It also means being attentive to how we interpret students' behaviour.
When a child rarely speaks during whole-class discussions, do we immediately assume that they lack confidence or agency? Or do we consider how classroom expectations, relationships and cultural experiences might influence their participation?
These questions matter because our interpretations shape the opportunities we create for students.
As Gay (2018) argues, culturally responsive teaching requires educators to recognize students' cultural experiences as meaningful resources for learning.
The goal is not to lower expectations for participation, but to broaden the ways students can meaningfully engage.
This is also a question of educational leadership
Although these reflections began in my classroom, I believe the implications extend beyond individual teaching practices.
Schools communicate expectations about participation through their curriculum, policies, assessment practices and professional cultures.
If student voice is understood primarily through one cultural perspective, these expectations may unintentionally privilege certain ways of communicating while overlooking others.
Khalifa et al. (2016) emphasize the importance of culturally responsive school leadership in creating environments that recognize and affirm students' identities.
This suggests that supporting student agency cannot rest solely on individual teachers.
School leaders also have a responsibility to create opportunities for educators to examine their assumptions about participation, share perspectives and develop approaches that respond to the cultural contexts of their students.
For international schools in particular, this raises broader questions about how globally promoted educational approaches are interpreted and practised within local communities.
Moving from recognition to action
Recognizing that students experience voice differently is an important starting point. But recognition alone is not enough.
Educators and school leaders can begin by examining how participation is defined and encouraged within their learning communities.
This might include involving students and families in conversations about voice, creating classroom routines that allow different forms of contribution, and providing professional learning opportunities that help teachers reflect on cultural expectations.
It also requires us to remain curious about students' experiences rather than making immediate judgments about their behaviour.
These changes may seem small, but they can influence whose contributions are recognized and whose perspectives are valued.
A final reflection
I continue to think about that moment in my Grade 1 classroom.
A simple suggestion during a conversation about classroom agreements revealed something much larger about the relationship between culture, authority and education.
It reminded me that student agency is not simply about encouraging children to speak more.
It is also about examining the conditions under which their voices are recognized, valued and able to influence their learning.
As educators, we often ask how we can give students more opportunities to express themselves.
Perhaps we should also be asking:
Are we creating classrooms where different ways of expressing voice are genuinely understood and valued?
Because meaningful student agency requires more than opportunities to speak. It requires environments where students can participate, be heard and exercise influence without having to leave their cultural identities behind.
References
- Gay, G. (2018). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice (3rd ed.). Teachers College Press.
- Khalifa, M. A., Gooden, M. A., & Davis, J. E. (2016). Culturally responsive school leadership: A synthesis of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 86(4), 1272–1311.
- Nyamekye, E., Zengulaaru, J., Addae, I., Mutawakil, A.-R., & Ntiakoh, G. B. (2025). Culture, critical pedagogy, and critical thinking among ‘children’ in Ghana: A critical discourse analysis of childhood constructions in Ghanaian proverbs. Journal of Asian and African Studies, 60(5), 3257–3272.
- Poonoosamy, M. (2018). Third culture kids' sense of international mindedness: Case studies of students in two International Baccalaureate schools. Journal of Research in International Education, 17(3), 207–227.
- Rubtsov, V. V. (2020). Two approaches to the problem of development in the context of social interactions: L. S. Vygotsky vs J. Piaget. Cultural-Historical Psychology, 16(3), 5–14.